Penny, a young lesbian living in Greenwich Village (who is hot and definitely knows it) spends much of her time preying on straight girls, whom she proceeds to lure into the lesbian lifestyle and subsequently “dominate” before moving on to the next. Penny lives with an older woman, Marcella, who is head-over-heels for Penny and who mindlessly provides for and protects her while receiving nothing but abuse in return. Soon Penny becomes obsessed with seducing Bernice, a young woman (with a fiance!) who is new to town and hoping to become an actress.
Penny is pretty much the worst human alive, a total caricature of the “predatory lesbian.” She makes no secret of her conniving ways—feeding Bernice ideas about how men (including Bernice’s fiance) are dangerous, lying to Bernice about being an actress herself. It turns out Penny will go to any lengths to get—and keep—Bernice within her grasp.
I Prefer Girls was both a horrifying and a fun read. It was definitely offensive to the utmost degree, so read it with a mountain of salt—and you’ll probably find it pretty entertaining.